Currently, the large organization I work for is undergoing a change of ownership. There are many employees and leaders here who have been with the company for 20+ years. With the change of ownership, the financials are being scrutinized. We are told there will be layoffs—which there have been every year for the past six years. Leadership is saying we need to “get on the train” and get behind their message. We are being told all employees are replaceable and there is no need to retain talent. I have a strong team who do an amazing job without asking for more. However, we can’t keep going at this pace. We are going to lose talented employees. They will go to places where they feel valued by executive leadership.
How do I keep morale up while my team is told they are all replaceable?
Dear Train Conductor,
Let me summarize quickly what you’ve told me:
1. Management doesn’t care about retention.
2. Your employees have options that would offer them more job security.
3. You want them to stick around and be engaged anyway.
If I understand your question correctly, you’re asking me to help you manipulate your employees to do something that is not in their best interest. I decline.
But perhaps you are asking me a different question. Perhaps you are saying, “Some of my employees want to stay in full knowledge of the risk. How can I help them derive enjoyment while working for a company that has no commitment to their interests?”
If this is your question, I offer the following vignette and counsel.
I worked with a remarkable leader named Mike Miller years ago. He led a group of 3,000 IT professionals on a mission-critical project to work themselves out of a job. Essentially, they were consolidating billing systems in a large telecom company in such a way that within 18 months, fewer than half of them would be needed. In spite of assured job insecurity, the team delivered on time, on budget, and on spec—and with stellar employee engagement. How?
1. Mutual commitment. Mike demonstrated that he cared about the interests of his employees. Now, Mike was not the CEO of the company. It’s possible those above him saw all of his people as “replaceable.” But Mike saw them as people. He loved and respected them. And he promised to do all he could to give them maximum flexibility in finding their next assignments. So they trusted him.
2. Reframe the deal. He was candid that for many of the team, this would be a project—not a career. Fortunately, many in the IT world are comfortable with this arrangement. He built trust by being honest about what was and was not available.
3. Be transparent. Mike knew that what his team valued was predictability. They could control their financial lives if they could avoid surprises. He ensured that people knew far in advance when layoffs would happen—and whom would be affected.
4. Make it about the work not the company. I once worked for a defense contractor who made some of the coolest military equipment in the world. Many of the employees were deeply cynical about management. They would lumber dejectedly into the massive parking lot outside the factory toward their car after a long day’s work. And yet, if on any particular day, one of their products was being tested in the adjacent proving ground, these same employees would stop in their tracks and stare in pride and awe. They may have hated the company, but they loved the product. Mike built a sense of passion and pride in his team by focusing them on the unprecedented technical challenge they were taking on. He framed it like President Kennedy did about putting a man on the moon. And his argument rang true—he caught talented employees’ imaginations in a way that helped them want to engage in the task itself—in spite of the company that saw them as tools.
If there is meaning to be mined in the work you do, and if you are willing to put the interests of your people on par with the interest of the company, you have every possibility of retaining your morality while engaging your people in the work you do.
5 thoughts on “How to Motivate an Undervalued Workforce”
Based on the fact that these employees were told that anyone is replaceable I would have given the advice that they ALL should look for a new job. Sounds like the new management does not appreciate or care about talent.
I totally agree, the current work situation, everyone is replaceable. Individuals need to know their own value and work to improve on it, Always expect the unexpected so that you will not be dejected.
Joseph, thanks so much for the integrity to decline the opportunity to teach manipulation and seek the moral high ground in the question. Just one more reason for my respect of what you guys are doing at Crucial Skills. Please keep it up-there’s great nobility in what you’re doing.
I’m reading your book “Change Anything” and I cannot get to any of the video’s you make reference to in the book.
They all know they will probably be looking for a new job. Potential new jobs come with recommendations from the current job. What better way to obtain a new job when your recommendation is good, instead of it saying “XXX slacked off on his current job since he knew he was replaceable?”