Crucial Skills®

A Blog by Crucial Learning

Crucial Conversations for Mastering Dialogue

My Coworkers Are Faking their Work. Should I Blow the Whistle?

Dear Crucial Skills,

My teacher and fellow interns regularly skip class but create fake attendance photos to make it look like they were there. I’ve been expected to appear in those photos, even though I know it’s dishonest. I don’t feel comfortable participating, but I’m afraid to speak up because everyone else seems to accept it. How can I address this situation without damaging my relationships or putting myself at risk?

Conflicted

Dear Conflicted,

What a tough situation you’re in. Perhaps you’ll be comforted to know that you’re not alone in wondering how to speak up when you feel like doing so will blow a whistle on the bad behavior of friends and peers.

Years ago, we surveyed nearly 1,000 people to learn how they respond when they observe something unethical happening around them. Nearly two-thirds of those we surveyed regularly witnessed ethical infractions, yet they reported blowing the whistle only about half of the time.

Why? Some of the reasons people gave for not speaking up were that they feared doing so would damage their career, that it would make it hard to work with the offenders, that they didn’t think they’d be taken seriously, or that they weren’t sure how to bring up their concerns. From my read of your question, you’re wrestling with the same feelings.

When you’re torn between your conscience and your relationships, it can be hard to know how to proceed. Since these are your peers, give them the benefit of the doubt by first addressing your concerns with them. When done skillfully, there’s a good chance this Crucial Conversation will help you move forward with both your integrity and your relationships intact.

Here are a few skills that can help you step up to that conversation with confidence:

Start with the Facts

Anytime we call another person on their behavior, it’s safe to assume you’ll encounter some level of denial, defensiveness, or both. Prepare for this outcome by gathering facts. State what you’ve observed. Strip your account of any accusations about what the behavior means to you. For example, don’t say, “You lied to the teacher.” Instead say, “Last week, you didn’t attend the class but submitted a photo that looked like you were there.” One is a fact and one is your interpretation of what the fact means. The clearer your data and the facts, the more likely you are to be heard.

Share Your Good Intentions

Next, let the other person know you have their best interest in mind. This shows your purpose is not to question their motives, but to deal with a possible problem before it spins out of control. Say something like, “I want you to do well in this class. I want all of us to do well. But I’m concerned that if the teacher learns you haven’t been attending, it will jeopardize your success and could also impact the entire class.”

Tentatively Share Your Concerns

As dishonest as the activity may seem or how clear your observations are, consider that there might be a reasonable explanation. Use tentative language to share your concerns. For example, “I’m not sure of your intentions, but I was tempted to conclude…”

Get the Other Person’s Point of View

Once you’ve described the facts, your intentions, and your concerns, ask the offender for their perspective or additional meaning. Perhaps the teacher is in on the ruse, perhaps they have different information than you. Be open to new possibilities. You’re trying to ensure you have all the facts before sharing your next steps.

Share Your Next Steps

If the new information you receive isn’t enough to change how you view the situation, now is your chance to share your plan. You are essentially giving the offender time to change their behavior or agree to the consequences your actions might trigger. Let them know where you stand: that you do not agree with falsifying attendance photos and you will not be participating. You can also let them know that if it continues, you’ll plan to inform the teacher of the behavior.

Whether you choose to draw the line at not participating or going further and informing the teacher is up to you. Unfortunately, there isn’t a set of skills to get you out of this moral quandary. You might feel contented with simply opting out and letting the rest of the class take the risk on their behavior. Or you might feel obligated to inform the teacher. Take time to decide what action you can live with and which one you can’t.

Unfortunately, we are surrounded by bad behavior—some we decide to call out and some we decide doesn’t warrant blowing the whistle likely because the consequences don’t seem dangerous or damaging enough to worry about. When it comes to deciding whether to speak up, I’ve found that if I can’t feel settled by my decision—that choosing to remain silent eats at me and I can’t find a sense of peace—then I need to act. If you feel this way, it’s likely the wrong decision for you. In the end, only you can be the steward of your moral compass.

One interesting thing we learned in our study is that standing up for what was right didn’t necessarily come easily—it took practice. Those who spoke up had just as much reason to believe the conversation might damage their career or result in repercussions from the offenders—and yet they spoke up anyway. These people reported feeling more confident in speaking up because they had practiced on smaller issues. Ultimately, the survey found that those who spoke up about small issues were six times more likely to report they raised a red flag on large issues.

If you want to be a more ethical person—one who speaks up when they observe unethical or unjust behavior—you need to practice in the moments that might seem inconsequential. It might not change the world, but it is building your capacity to do what is right when it really counts.

Best,
Brittney

Build the Skills Behind the Insight
The ideas expressed in this article are rooted in the principles and behaviors taught in the course. Learn more in Crucial Conversations for Mastering Dialogue.
Learn More
Get Insights
The ideas expressed in this article are rooted in the principles and behaviors taught in the course. Learn more in

Crucial Conversations
For Mastering Dialogue

icon
Ask a Question
Want advice from our authors and experts? Send us your questions!
Ask Now
icon
Subscribe
Take advantage of our free, award-winning newsletter—delivered straight to your inbox.
Subscribe
Recommended Blog Posts

Why Their Behavior Is Driving You Crazy
Read
When AI Use Starts to Erode Trust at Work
Read
How to Share Feedback as a New Employee
Read

Leave a reply